This is a collection of multiple parts covering qol, gov transparency and other reworks.
Election system:
Approval voting is nice for election one winner, in our case the gov. But the system fails if there is more than one “winner” position and we are back to strategic voting again as in a 3 seat government the two parliament members can overrule the Gov despite representing less voters. This system leads to a lot of votes being lost as “duplicate” candidates can just fill the seats and thus votes are also often misrepresented.
My proposal: Basically the old system but the candidates are weighted in motions accoring to the amount of votes they got. Example:
100 players vote, every player has one vote
4 candidates (A-D), 3 seats
A gets 40 votes, B gets 30, C gets 20, D gets 10
=> 10 votes are lost, two candidates have to work together to pass a motion (depending on how it it is implemented B and C could not pass a motion together as they only represent 50% of the voters which is not a majority meaning A is the only one able to pass motions if they find a partner)
=> because there are no unnessesary “filler”/“duplicate” candidates needed one player represents one political faction which means that parliaments become way diverser and parliament roles become more meaningful
Splitting politics and management:
Planetary and gateway management can already use up multiple seats leaving no space for actual politics. The Gov could for example elected through a approval voting where the winner gets the job and make motions with 1 motion weight, doubling as a tie breaker (see election example). Or Gov and other managers could be appointed by the parliament through a motion. Aside from one “Gov” and multiple “managers” which can put up motions it could also be possible to add “spectators” which can see the gov screen but not make motions or vote on them. This would be useful for players interested in government mechanics.
Making CoGC a motion:
Per gov term there are 5 elections, 4x CoGC and one for gov. With 20 bases this means over 3 elections per day where CoGC doesn’t change 99% of time. It is not rarely the case that nobody votes for CoGC or somebody accidentally votes for something wrong (PIO) which then changes it for one week despite nobody on the planet wanting it.
Making it a motion on the planets with ADM would reduce (unnessesary) votings by 80% drastically reducing voting fatigue and giving a topic to make politics about. Maybe there could be a field in ADM in which the candidates can select for which CoGC they are running.
Giving gov access to WAR and buy/sell motions:
This would take the storage burden away from the Gov while also enabling parliament members to fill CoGC and POPI if the Gov is absent with the materials the gov owns. It would also make the paperwork easier and more transparent as the gov can just buy materials compared to the current “trust me bro” CoGC/POPI payouts.
CoGC could also automatically pull from the WAR to fill itself reducing micromanagement for govs, maybe POPI too (having a checkbox in each POPI building material for example).
Making FINIS monthly instead of weekly, or both:
CoGC has a 10d cycle and POPI a 15d so looking at the two last two 7d cycles doesn’t make much sense, and for example because of bigger production orders the tax income can change from week to week. Having 30d (or simply months) would be way more helpful.
More data in general for govs:
Which profession and worker class pays how much of the total income? Currently that is a pure guessing game and how production fees are calculated doesn’t help
Definitely agree CoGC needs to be a motion, and having “spectators” in government would be very nice as well (maybe just everyone that loses becomes one).
I actually disagree strongly with your assessment that approval voting fails for more than one winners. I think it is one of the few places it works extremely well. When you get to cast a vote for multiple people, you’re saying “I’m OK with any of these people being in government”. The top [X] that the most people agree on form the government, in this case giving the best overall representation. I do think some work needs to be done on the apportionment of power; currently, governor only really means something in a very divided parliament. My suggestion would be to rework the difference in position between parliament and governor. For example, make governor the executive (only recipient of motions, excepting contractors; in charge of completing contracts, etc.) and the parliament an actual legislature (makes and passes all motions). I don’t think the voting system would need to change for this to work, and as an added bonus it would be a nice test and practice case for more general contexts (gov. vs. MP).
Lastly, while I think weighted voting is nice in theory, it’s really only a problem right now when there are so few people to vote. A handful of votes can decide an election currently, but if there were 10x the players I suspect the numbers would end up a lot more even between candidates, esp. due to the approval system.
Strongly disagree. The problem is that there can be as many candidates for one political party as they want.
This means that there is no representation but instead just one ruling party. And because you can’t down vote somebody it means that you can have 60% of the voters in two conservative parties run against each other and then there comes a third party with 40% getting the whole parliament (no matter how many seats) and thus the party that 60% don’t like has uncontested rule.
So you either need the ability to down vote, or to have weighted votes. Though either can again lead to the same outcome as it is a strategic three way fight with many unknown variables. All this results in different votitng patterns being weighted different and a very bad representation of the actual voters.
So just giving everyone one vote and having this vote translate into motions as weight of the candidate would be a simple and effective solution as everyone can vote for what they want without any strategic thoughts as every voter is worth the same.
More people would still not solve the “winner takes it all” problem and the bad voter representation. A single bigger party can likely easily dominate wherever they go even when most people are against them because they are also against others weakening their own “planetary defense”.
And the low amount of voter participation is mainly because there is just nothing to make politics about. There are a lot of votes but nothing ever changes until it does and then the chaos is big.
That aside good luck getting 10x the players into the current universe, the planet limits will be a problem before you will reach the mass that you want. Some bigger non starters are already filled up a fair bit, Kiruna for example is filled to ~40% and even full and with political topics the voter pool will probably be somewhere around 50-200 people.